Sport List >Home NFL MLB NCAA Football Golf MMA/Boxing NLL DRAFT
NBA NHL NCAA Basketball Soccer 1 on 1 Racing Other
 

Contact the Mailbag if you have any Sports Questions 
Mailbag@
informativesports.com



 

 

 

The PUCKHEAD MAILBAG

By Ethan Calof

Vol I,Vol II, Vol III

Welcome to the fourth edition of the Puckhead Mailbag, and welcome to the very first edition broadcast primarily to InformativeSports.com!  

Before I begin, I have to relay the not-so-recent news that Ottawa Senators have fired head coach Craig Hartsburg. Cory Clouston, their minor league head coach who was named the interim coach, becomes their fourth head coach in two years.  

I’ve always been a hater of sorts towards the entire Ottawa Senators organization, especially their management miscues that left whoever’s at the helm with an un-coachable team. Hartsburg was a dead man walking from the moment he accepted the Senators head job. GM Brian Murray is prone to firing the coaches to cover his own behind and his own mistakes: his bad player choices, his poor hiring decision with former coach John Paddock, and his poor handling of the team as a whole.  

The reality is that Hartsburg is not a bad coach. He just needed players willing to listen to him, and a management team willing to let him enact his system. The precipitous decline of the team’s record is not at all related to his coaching. In a way, I kind of feel happy for Hartsburg, because he’s not saddled with a doomed team anymore. He can go back to Junior, where he can work his magic all over again.

Before I delve into this week’s questions, I have to recant a statement I made in my last issue. Responding to a question about the worst team to have ever won the Stanley Cup, I erroneously fingered the 1907 Kenora Thistles. Upon further contemplation, however, I have to cast my vote for the Cup winner that truly stands above them all: the 1937-38 Chicago Blackhawks.

This team ended the regular season with a record of 14 wins, 25 losses, and 9 ties, by far the worst among Cup winners. They scored the fewest goals in the NHL that year, and allowed the second most. And yet, in the playoffs, they caught fire behind the sterling play of goalie Mike Karakas.

Karakas, however, was injured heading into the Stanley Cup Finals against the Toronto Maple Leafs. The Leafs, probably scoffing at the Hawks’ hopes, allowed them to use Leaf minor leaguer Alfie Moore in nets for the first game, and he played brilliantly in the first game, a 3-1 win. The Leafs then pulled away Moore from the Hawks, yet Karakas returned in time to lead Chicago to a 3-1 series victory that nobody dreamt was possible.

Now, onto your questions, which mark the return of The Captain to the mailbag…

Has anyone ever died playing hockey?

            -The Captain, Saint Leo

There are quite a few people who have died due to an on-ice injury. I’ll only discuss the North American professional players who have passed away due to on-ice injuries.

Owen McCourt was the very first. His death came via mass bludgeoning on the head from opposing players’ sticks during a brawl between his Cornwall team against the Ottawa Vics. The players who attacked him were charged with manslaughter.

Next came Edgar Dey, a member of the famous Dey family in Ottawa , who played for the Halifax Crescents. He died of a head injury, though I could not find out what specifically caused it.

Likely the most famous on-ice death came in 1937, when Hall of Famer and Montreal legend Howie Morenz passed away after complications following his broken leg. He broke the leg in four places after getting his skate stuck in a rut in the ice, being hit there by Chicago Blackhawks defender Earl Seibert. Months later, he died. His funeral was broadcast across Canada , and thousands attended his funeral at the Montreal Forum.

The last death to occur during a North American professional league came in 1968, when Bill Masterton passed away following an on-ice head injury. The Minnesota North Star had just made a pass to his teammate when he was checked by two members of the Oakland Seals. He fell backwards, and hit the back of his unhelmeted head hard on the ice, causing severe damage. His death sparked the movement for helmet use in the NHL, which eventually became mandated ten years later.

Now, time for something less morbid…

After a fight, do teams go four-on-four or five-on-five?

            -Clueless in Carolina

After a fight, the teams go five-on-five, with the two offending players going to the penalty box. The players only return to the bench at the next whistle after their penalties end.

Back to morbid…

G’day! You will probably find this hard to answer, but does Dallas have Detroit ’s measure and should the other teams get the tapes?

            -The Aussie Hockey Fan, Warragul

After consulting my handy-dandy Aussie-North American Dictionary, the question became clear to me. Why do I think that Dallas has three wins over Detroit , and should other teams learn from this?

To be honest, I have very little clue as to why the Fighting Averies have been so successful over Detroit this season. I have my theories, however. The Stars are a team that traditionally wakes up against Detroit , always refusing to die in this quasi-rivalry (I say quasi because there is absolutely no bad blood yet). They hop on Detroit ’s speedy players and force them to bang their bodies, and this throws the Red Wings’ puck possession schemes off their normal trajectory.

As for what other teams can learn, it has to be that in order to hop on the Red Wings, you need to force them to play your style instead of being wrapped up in theirs. You need to jump on them early to stop them from setting up their enormously successful passing webs. Basically, you can’t let them budge.

To continue this Dallas-heavy mailbag, here comes a question from a new reader…

Is Mike Modano still an elite two-way centre in the NHL?

            -The Only Polar Bear in Dallas

The short answer to this one: no. Of course, you aren’t reading this mailbag just to see short answers, though, so I’ll elaborate.

When watching Modano play nowadays, it’s quite clear that he’s lost more than a step from his glory days. His points totals are down, his speed is down, and his overall effectiveness is down. What he hasn’t lost, though, is his grit and determination, which makes this question valid.

At this point in the twilight of his career, there’s absolutely no comparison between him and the elite two-way players on the league today. Guys like Henrik Zetterberg, Pavel Datsyuk, and Mike Richards are all better offensively, faster, and better defensively. Modano just doesn’t belong in that group.

Time for another set of questions from a regular contributor…

In your last mailbag, you talked about the ECAHA. Was that the first hockey league ever? If not, what was? And who were the original teams in the NHL?

            -The Rookie, Germantown

The ECAHA was definitely not the first hockey league. It was founded in 1905, but disbanded in 1909 over a dispute between team owners and businesses. These short-term leagues were common during the early history of professional ice hockey.

The honour of the first ever hockey league goes to a local league formed in Kingston in 1883. However, little is known about it. The first “real” league was the Amateur Hockey Association of Canada (AHAC). Founded in 1886, it was created with the express purpose of providing a longer season to determine the Canadian hockey champions. In 1893, the Montreal AAA of the AHAC became the first league to win the Stanley Cup. They disbanded in 1898, giving way to the CAHL.

As for the NHL, the original teams were not actually the Original Six. The league was founded to block out hated Eddie Livingstone, the owner of the Toronto Blueshirts, and consisted of the Montreal Canadiens, Montreal Wanderers, Ottawa Senators, and Toronto Arenas.

Time for one last question…

Why do hockey fans hate Gary Bettman so much?

            -Know-It-All, Dagobah

There are very few names that universally boil the blood of all hockey fans, whether from Detroit , Colorado , Philadelphia , Toronto , Montreal , Minneapolis , Boston , or Calgary . This stumpy American lawyer with basketball has often been unfairly accused of helping the game of hockey by growing it. The fact remains that he has presided over some of the baffling moments in NHL history.

Consider the fact that no other commissioner in NHL history had ever been in charge of a labour stoppage before Bettman. Now, consider that Bettman has been privy to not one, but two labour stoppages. One wiped out half of a season, the other wiped out an entire season. Most hockey fans enjoy actually watching their hockey, as opposed to reading about why it isn’t there.

Then, you need to look at his failed quixotic quest into the Southern U.S. Most of the teams that he has put in places like Tampa and Atlanta are floundering, with no money and even fewer fans. Not only that, but he’s hindering efforts to move those teams back to Canada , where they would be appreciated and supported. The fact that he’s diluting the game with crap teams layered on crap locations makes us hockey fans angry.

There are many other lowlights of his tenure. There’s the fact that he actually knows very little about the game of hockey. There’s the fact that he’s been accused of being anti-Canadian. But there is one central fact: he truly believes that the NHL isn’t a top-tier league. He’s leading the league into a wasteland, and no true hockey fan will support that.

 

Submitted  2009

Comment on this article to Comments@informativesports.com